Teacher-centred versus Student-centred learning: Similarities, Differences and Benefits.

Dr. Heena Rachh
Oct 22, 2022
Learning, School
📚 Download our FREE School Brochure now!
Start your child's journey to success.
×

What empowers your child's learning ability? Flexibility, interest, or relevance. The answer varies, depending on the child's personality. Two kinds of learning hone the child's abilities: learner-centric and teacher-centric. An International school in Tokyo, like Global IB School, prefers to follow a learner-centric approach. 

Let's learn what it is and how it impacts the child's abilities.

A learner-centred environment facilitates leadership skills among the students and makes them feel independent. It is the student who chooses what and how to learn. It all happens under the supervision of an instructor. 

The process is designed so the children can learn the best.  

However, in teacher-centric, the focus is completely on the educator. Both the approaches have their differences, similarities, etc. let's learn about them in detail. 

What is a teacher-centred approach? 

In a teacher-centred classroom approach, the instructor takes centre stage and focuses completely on the educator. The teacher gives instructions and does almost all the talking while the students remain silent and listen to them. The child is encouraged to participate in the activities, but the teacher-student collaboration is missing in the teacher centred approach. 

Please check if your Child is Eligible for Scholaships!
×

Characteristics of a teacher-centred classroom

In this approach, the full control lies in the hand of the teacher, and the activities are completed in their presence. Therefore, the classroom remains in order, and students stay quiet. One benefit of a teacher-centred approach is that since the teacher is conducting all the activities, there is no chance of missing any important material or content.  

However, the traditional approach comes with a set of disadvantages too. It hinders the communication and collaborative skills of the students, and it creates monotony in the classroom, making the class boring and pressurising. The approach is less powerful in making students learn the concepts because their focus gets disturbed. Even the students start fearing the teacher and are hesitant to express themselves. This approach discourages the children from asking logical questions. 

What is a learner-centred approach?

In a teacher-centred approach, the teacher plays a pivotal role in the classroom. However, the students and teacher have an equal focus on student-centred learning. The student-teacher collaboration is common, and here the learners don't play the role of mute spectators; instead, they communicate and collaborate. 

Characteristics of student-centred learning

One of the main benefits of the student-centred classroom is it helps the students to gain confidence, imbibe communication skills, and learn on their own through group work.  

Additionally, it gives learners the freedom to ask logical questions from the teacher. Such a class is far from boring. The learners and educators remain enthusiastic during the learning process, so the students learn and retain better. 

Further, it matches the learning style of the different students.  

Similarities between teacher-centred and Student-centred approaches

● Both teacher-centred and student-centred approaches use these methods in the classroom to improve the student's learning process. 

● In both approaches, the education is conducted under the supervision of the learner and the knowledge is imparted effectively. 

Differences between student and teacher-centric approach

Here we have created a tabulated form about teacher centred versus student-centred learning.

Basis of difference

 

Teacher centric

 

Student-centric

 

What is student-centred learning and teacher-centred learning?

 

In the teacher-centric approach, the focus is on the educator. He plays a major role.

 

In a student-centric approach, the focus is on the learner, and the steps are taken to make them stay independent.

 

  Communication

 

In a teacher-centric approach, the children are hesitant to communicate with the teachers and don't even ask logical questions. Most of them stay mum.

 

In a learner-centred classroom, communication and collaboration are developed to make the learning process easy and effective.

 

Collaboration

 

In the teacher-centred method, the relationship between the students and teachers remains distant. The students take the lecture and leave the class. 

 

In the learner-centric environment, the learning process is absorbed, and the child discovers the meaning of different concepts by collaborating with the teacher. Regular interaction happens between the teacher and the students.

 

Method of learning

 

The teacher-centric approach follows the traditional learning method to make the students learn.

 

In a student-centred approach, the instructors become facilitators and subjects are taught interactively with the help of games and other fun exercises.

 

Engagement

 

There is very less engagement of students and teachers in this approach; hence the class tends to be boring and sometimes overwhelming for the students to attend.

 

The engagement is high between teachers and students; hence the class is not boring.

 

Who elevates the learning process?

  Who evaluates the learning?

 

The instructor elevates the learning process.

The teachers evaluate the student learning process.

 

The students have some control over the topics.

The students and instructors both evaluate the learning process.

 

Who selects the topics to discuss?

 

The instructors select the topics to discuss.

 

The students can select some topics for discussion. 

 

  Who answers the questions?

 

The teacher answers the questions of all the students.

 

The instructor doesn't answer the students' questions; rather, he acts as an information resource.

 

Role of instructor

 

The instructor corrects the students at every moment.

 

The instructor acts as a facilitator and corrects the students at the end when the feedback or correction needs arise.

 

How does the student work?

 

In this approach, the student works independently. 

 

In this approach, the student works in pairs or groups.

 

Classroom

 

In a teacher-centred approach, the classroom remains strict and orderly.

 

In student-centred learning, the learners have the freedom to acquire knowledge at their pace.

 

Benefits of a Teacher-Centred Classroom

● In a teacher-centred approach, the classroom stays orderly and quiet because the educator has full responsibility.

● Since students learn on their own; hence they stay independent.

● Since all the responsibility falls on the head of the instructor; hence there is no chance of missing the topic.

● With this approach, it becomes easy to achieve academic goals.

● The approach may seem psychologically sound because it is conducted under the instruction of an expert teacher.

● The subject matter is logically arranged. 

Benefits of a student-centred classroom

● The students learn important skills through collaboration and group efforts.

● The students direct the learning process, ask questions and do the tasks independently.

● The classroom is not boring, and students absorb more due to the interactive teaching methods. 

● The personalised approach is developed between teachers and students.

● There is a deep connection between student interests and school curriculum.

● Learning plans are created to suit the individual student's interest.

● Flexibility and adaptability are the main benefits of this approach.

● The approach helps the students to learn and adjust to the different environments.

● The students can learn from their mistakes.

● It develops critical thinking among the students.

● It teaches the students specific learning techniques that improve their learning process.

● The students introspect where they went wrong, boosting their self-reflection skills. 

Conclusion

Since both techniques have advantages, you might be confused about which one to select. An answer is a student-centric approach. The student-centric approach is the best because it eliminates the child's resistance and makes him feel confident. 

The international school in Tokyo, the Global IB School, follows this approach and encourages students' expression and communication ability by providing them with the right learning environment.  Our school helps prompt the learners to learn progressively.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the types of learner-centered curricula?

Types of learner-centered curricula include problem-based learning, project-based learning, and inquiry-based learning. These approaches prioritize student engagement, collaboration, and critical thinking, aligning with the learner-centred approach.

Are there specific subjects or disciplines where one approach tends to be more effective than the other?

Yes, certain subjects or disciplines may benefit more from a teacher-centered approach, like foundational subjects requiring direct instruction, while student-centered approaches are often more effective for creative or critical thinking subjects like art or philosophy.

How does student-centred learning promote critical thinking skills?

Student-centered learning promotes critical thinking by empowering students to actively engage in their education. It encourages inquiry, problem-solving, and collaboration, fostering independence and deeper understanding of subjects.


Category


Annual Gross family income bracket (YEN)


Value of Scholarship
(Waiver on Tuition fees)

A

Below 3,000,000

25%

B

3,000,000-4,000,000

13%

C

4,000,000-5,000,000

11%

D

5,000,000-6,000,000

6%

E

6,000,000-8,000,000

4%

F

8,000,000-10,000,000

3%

G

10,000,000-12,000,000

2%

Dr. Heena Rachh

Related Topics

More from same author

Chat with counsellor

Enquire Now

Featured Blogs

Top Scholarships

Global Citizen Scholarship

Eligibility:

93 % and Above or A*

Learn More

9GEMS Holistic Development Scholarship

Eligibility:

Talent Based - 9 GEMS

Learn More

Hideki Yukawa Global Skills Scholarship

Eligibility:

Talent Based - Technology

Learn More

Sadako Ogata Merit cum Means Scholarship

Eligibility:

GROSS FAMILY INCOME : Below 3,000,000 YEN to 12,000,000 YEN

Learn More

Global FUTURE-READY Merit Scholarship

Eligibility:

90 % Above or A*

Learn More
×
POP-UP
×
×